As the Premier League season roars into its final third, the drama intensifies not only at the top of the table but also among clubs facing existential questions about their identity, form, and future. Manchester United, once the pinnacle of English footballing dominance, finds itself languishing in chaotic disarray, prompting pundits and fans alike to question whether relegation-level performances are truly beneath them anymore. Meanwhile, Liverpool’s Trent Alexander-Arnold continues to oscillate between brilliance and bewilderment in the spotlight, and Tottenham Hotspur remains caught in a frustrating cycle of fragility that threatens to derail yet another promising campaign.
This week’s biggest hits and misses don’t just reflect fleeting headlines; they shine a glaring spotlight on deep-rooted systemic flaws, unstable mentalities, and managerial conundrums.
Manchester United Deserving of Relegation Zone Scrutiny
Erik ten Hag’s Manchester United has become a tale of missed expectations and uninspired performances. Despite the club’s deep pockets and a roster studded with international stars, the Red Devils continue to stumble, particularly in matches where grit and cohesion matter most.
-
Tactical Disarray
Ten Hag’s system — if it can still be called that — has suffered from inconsistency and a lack of identity. The high-press model that worked intermittently last season now appears disjointed. Players seem unsure of roles, spatial positioning is poor, and the midfield is often bypassed with ease.
In a recent fixture, United looked listless and disorganized within the first 30 minutes. The lack of communication between center-backs, the gaping holes in midfield, and the predictable play out wide were signs of a team that has lost its way.
-
Mental Fragility
More than tactics, it’s United’s mental game that is most concerning. The players seem bereft of confidence and belief, especially when conceding the first goal. Body language turns sour, heads drop, and composure vanishes. For a team with such history, this mentality is startlingly weak.
-
Leadership Void
With Bruno Fernandes wearing the armband, there’s been growing concern about the lack of vocal, rallying leadership. United legends like Roy Keane and Nemanja Vidic embodied warrior spirits; Fernandes, in contrast, often appears frustrated and isolated when the chips are down.
Trent Alexander-Arnold Genius Under Fire
Trent Alexander-Arnold has long been the poster boy for the modern fullback — redefining what the position can be with his laser-like crosses, vision, and playmaking from deep. Yet, with every inch of praise comes criticism — and often, valid.
-
Defensive Concerns
No conversation about Trent is complete without a mention of his defensive frailties. In recent matches, particularly away from home, his positional lapses have cost Liverpool dearly. Whether it’s being caught too high up the pitch or failing to track back in time, opponents have identified him as a weak point to exploit.
-
The “Circus” Around His Persona
Trent’s growing media presence, combined with his unique role in Jurgen Klopp’s tactical blueprint, has turned him into a focal point for both admiration and ridicule. The so-called “circus” surrounding him includes debates about whether he should be played in midfield, whether he’s undroppable, and whether his flair justifies his shortcomings.
-
The Midfield Solution
Klopp has tried to move Trent into a hybrid role — a roaming inverted fullback who acts as a deep-lying playmaker. While the results have been mixed, the experiment reflects how much faith the manager places in his talents. However, until he masters both phases of the game consistently, his inclusion will remain a divisive topic.
Tottenham Hotspur Fragile Foundations
Tottenham entered the season with cautious optimism. Ange Postecoglou brought a breath of fresh air, implementing a possession-based, high-octane style. For a while, Spurs dazzled. But as injuries and reality bit, the familiar fragility crept in.
-
Defensive Woes Return
For all of Spurs’ attacking flair, their defense remains a glass house. Injuries to Micky van de Ven and Cristian Romero have disrupted rhythm, and makeshift pairings have exposed a lack of depth. The fullbacks — particularly on the right — have struggled against elite wingers, and individual errors have cost them dearly.
-
Lack of Mental Toughness
Just like Manchester United, Tottenham has a recurring problem: they crumble under pressure. After conceding, Spurs often lose rhythm and structure, unable to mount meaningful comebacks. The lack of resilience was evident in recent fixtures where a single goal turned momentum entirely against them.
-
Son and the Scoring Burden
Heung-min Son continues to carry the scoring load, but the lack of support is glaring. Richarlison remains inconsistent, and other attacking options haven’t stepped up when needed. Unless more players share the burden, Spurs’ top-four hopes may collapse under the weight of overreliance.
A Broader Crisis of Identity
What unites United, Liverpool (through Trent), and Spurs is a broader identity crisis within the Premier League. Clubs with storied pasts or high expectations are finding it increasingly hard to adapt to modern football’s demands: pressing at pace, playing out from the back, managing egos, and maintaining mental sharpness week in, week out.
The Premier League’s relentless schedule doesn’t allow for long slumps. Unlike leagues in Europe with fewer top-tier challengers, England’s top flight punishes complacency, lack of depth, and strategic confusion almost instantly.
Hits and Misses of the Week
-
Hit: Cole Palmer’s Consistency at Chelsea
In the middle of Stamford Bridge’s chaos, Palmer continues to impress. His creativity, maturity, and vision belie his age. He is fast becoming the heartbeat of Chelsea’s rebuild.
-
Hit: Aston Villa’s Emery Engine
Unai Emery has quietly turned Aston Villa into a tactically mature, dangerous unit. Their balance of attack and defense, anchored by Douglas Luiz and led by Ollie Watkins, is making waves.
-
Miss: Man Utd’s Tactical Confusion
Ten Hag’s inability to impose a recognizable system, along with confusing substitutions and reactive setups, continues to bewilder fans and pundits alike.
-
Miss: Spurs’ Lack of Plan B
When things go south for Tottenham, they have no effective alternative strategy. Their Plan A is bold but brittle, and there’s little sign Postecoglou has instilled a reliable fallback.
-
Miss: Trent’s Polarizing Presence
The debate around Trent Alexander-Arnold is valid but also exhausting. He is either the savior or the scapegoat — there’s rarely any middle ground.
Fan Reactions and Media Pressure
The media microscope is particularly harsh on clubs like Manchester United, Liverpool, and Spurs. Every misstep is amplified, every shortcoming dissected. For players like Trent or Fernandes, even social media interactions can spark debates. The burden of expectations can either crush or create legends.
Meanwhile, fan reactions vary from passionate pleas to fury. At United, protests about ownership continue to simmer alongside frustration at poor performances. Spurs fans, long patient, are beginning to demand tangible progress. And at Liverpool, while Klopp still enjoys goodwill, questions about squad depth and balance grow louder.
Also Read:
