When Manchester United unveiled Ruben Amorim as their new manager earlier this summer, the appointment was greeted with a blend of curiosity, optimism, and cautious skepticism. The Portuguese tactician, renowned for his bold ideas and successful tenure at Sporting CP, was stepping into one of the most challenging jobs in football: steering the Red Devils back to the top of English and European football. The first litmus test of his tenure was not on the pitch but in the transfer market, as Amorim and United’s hierarchy faced the critical task of reshaping the squad during his inaugural summer transfer window.
This article takes a deep dive into how Ruben Amorim navigated that crucial period, the strategies he employed, the challenges he encountered, and what his moves reveal about Manchester United’s trajectory under his stewardship.
The Context A Club in Transition
Manchester United entered the 2024 summer transfer window in a state of flux. The club had endured several turbulent seasons under multiple managers, oscillating between rebuilding phases without a clear, sustained identity. Erik ten Hag’s departure left the team once again searching for direction. Enter Amorim, a coach praised for his tactical ingenuity and ability to rejuvenate squads.
However, expectations were immense. United’s fan base demanded progress in the Premier League and Europe, while the club’s ownership — amidst boardroom politics and restructuring — sought stability and fiscal responsibility. Amorim’s first window, therefore, had to balance ambition with pragmatism.
Setting the Priorities
Upon his arrival, Amorim and the recruitment team identified several pressing needs:
- A commanding central defender to shore up a defense prone to injuries and inconsistency.
- A mobile central midfielder capable of dictating play and pressing aggressively.
- A reliable striker to complement or challenge Rasmus Højlund, ensuring depth in attack.
- Squad trimming to offload underperforming or surplus players and reduce the wage bill.
Amorim was clear about one thing: United’s rebuild needed to focus on younger, hungry talents who could adapt to his system, rather than relying solely on marquee signings.
Defensive Reinforcements Stability First
United’s defensive struggles in the previous campaign highlighted the necessity for reinforcement. Injuries to Raphael Varane, Lisandro Martínez, and Luke Shaw had left the backline exposed, with makeshift solutions undermining consistency.
Amorim pushed for the acquisition of a versatile defender, and United secured Jean-Clair Todibo from Nice. The Frenchman’s ball-playing ability and athleticism aligned perfectly with Amorim’s preference for defenders comfortable initiating play from the back. Todibo’s arrival also symbolized a shift: rather than chasing overpriced stars, United were targeting players on the cusp of elite status.
Additionally, Amorim oversaw the promotion of academy prospect Willy Kambwala into a more prominent role, reinforcing his commitment to blending youth with experience.
Midfield Overhaul Control and Energy
Perhaps the most critical area for Amorim was midfield. United’s struggles in controlling games had been glaring, with Casemiro’s decline in mobility leaving gaps that opponents exploited. Amorim insisted on signing a dynamic midfielder who could anchor his high-pressing, transition-heavy system.
The marquee acquisition came in the form of João Neves, the teenage prodigy from Benfica. Neves, hailed as one of Europe’s brightest talents, brought energy, intelligence, and composure on the ball. Though his price tag raised eyebrows, Amorim viewed Neves as a long-term cornerstone around whom the midfield could be rebuilt.
To complement him, Amorim greenlit a deal for Sofyan Amrabat’s permanent signing, ensuring depth and physicality. Christian Eriksen and Scott McTominay were retained for experience and rotational purposes, though Amorim reportedly encouraged the club to listen to offers for Donny van de Beek.
The Striker Situation Finding Balance in Attack
Rasmus Højlund had shown flashes of brilliance but also inconsistency in his first season. Amorim recognized the need for another striker to share the burden. United were linked with high-profile forwards, but financial constraints limited options.
Ultimately, the club secured Brian Brobbey from Ajax, a forward Amorim admired for his pace, strength, and familiarity with a pressing style. Brobbey was not just a backup but a player capable of competing with Højlund for the starting role, thereby raising standards in the squad.
Meanwhile, Amorim placed renewed faith in Marcus Rashford, tasking him to rediscover form under a clearer tactical framework. Antony and Alejandro Garnacho were retained as key wide options, though Amorim privately emphasized the need for more consistency from them.
Outgoings Trimming the Fat
Equally important as signings were departures. Amorim, keen on instilling a merit-based culture, had little patience for players who were either underperforming or did not fit his system.
- Harry Maguire, once club captain, was sold to West Ham to free up wages and playing time for younger defenders.
- Anthony Martial, plagued by injuries and inconsistency, departed on a free transfer.
- Van de Beek, after several loan spells, finally left in search of regular football.
- Brandon Williams and Eric Bailly were also moved on, ending their peripheral roles.
These exits not only streamlined the squad but also sent a message: Amorim was building a team in his image, with no room for sentimentality.
Navigating Financial Constraints
One of Amorim’s biggest challenges was navigating the financial realities of United’s situation. With UEFA’s Financial Fair Play regulations looming and the club’s massive wage bill, big-money signings had to be carefully justified.
Amorim’s solution was a mixture of strategic investments in young talent and prudent sales. While Neves commanded a hefty fee, other acquisitions like Todibo and Brobbey were relatively affordable compared to United’s past splurges. Moreover, the emphasis on youth development meant the club could save on short-term fixes.
Tactical Vision Reflected in Transfers
Amorim’s signings were not random but reflected his tactical philosophy:
- From Defense to Attack: Todibo’s passing range and comfort under pressure were key to Amorim’s preference for building play from the back.
- Midfield Dynamism: Neves and Amrabat provided the blend of energy and control required for pressing and quick transitions.
- Versatility in Attack: Brobbey’s mobility and Rashford’s adaptability gave United the flexibility to alternate between direct counterattacks and structured possession play.
The recruitment strategy showed a move away from “big name” chases toward building a cohesive, balanced squad.
Fan Reactions Hope and Skepticism
Unsurprisingly, the fan base was divided. Many praised Amorim for his clear vision and decisive approach, contrasting it with the muddled recruitment strategies of recent years. The arrival of young talents like Neves excited supporters who craved a long-term project.
However, skeptics argued that United still lacked the elite-level depth of rivals like Manchester City and Arsenal. Questions lingered about whether Brobbey could deliver consistently, or whether Neves could handle the pressure of being United’s midfield linchpin so early in his career.
Amorim himself acknowledged the skepticism but insisted the club was laying foundations for sustained success rather than quick fixes.
Early Signs on the Pitch
Preseason offered glimpses of Amorim’s philosophy in action. United showcased a more aggressive press, quicker ball circulation, and greater reliance on younger players. Neves impressed with his maturity, while Todibo slotted seamlessly into the defense. Brobbey, too, made an impact with his direct runs.
Amorim’s willingness to rotate and trust academy players suggested a culture shift. Players like Kobbie Mainoo and Garnacho were given prominent roles, underlining his commitment to youth.
Challenges Ahead
Despite the positive steps, challenges remain. United’s squad depth still lags behind top competitors, and injuries could derail progress. Moreover, the Premier League’s intensity will test whether young players like Neves and Mainoo can deliver consistently.
Amorim also faces the daunting task of managing expectations. United fans demand trophies, and patience is often in short supply. Balancing long-term rebuilding with the immediate need for results will be his biggest test.
What the Future Holds
Looking beyond the summer window, Amorim’s blueprint is clear:
- Youth Development will remain central, with academy graduates given pathways to the first team.
- Targeted Signings will prioritize system fit over marquee names.
- Cultural Reset will emphasize discipline, accountability, and collective effort.
If executed successfully, Amorim could finally end United’s cycle of false dawns and establish a sustainable identity akin to Sir Alex Ferguson’s long-lasting dynasty.
Also Read:
- SBOTOP Carabao Cup Third Round: Liverpool and Arsenal Feature as Every Match Streams Live on Sky Sports
- SBOTOP: Union Berlin Women Eye Champions League Glory After Promotion as Fan Support Soars Across Europe
- SBOTOP: Ryan Christie Admits Scotland ‘Desperate’ to Reach World Cup as Self-Imposed Pressure Mounts
