The weekend of Women’s Super League action produced another set of compelling narratives, with Manchester City’s star striker Khadija “Bunny” Shaw once again stealing the spotlight. Shaw’s clinical double from the penalty spot guided City to an emphatic victory, underlining her status as one of the league’s most lethal forwards. Meanwhile, across the divide, Liverpool’s woes under manager Gareth Taylor deepened as they fell to a dispiriting 2-0 defeat against Manchester United.
These contrasting results highlight the shifting dynamics within the WSL. On one hand, City continue to look like serious title contenders, buoyed by Shaw’s form and a squad brimming with confidence. On the other, Liverpool remain in a rut, struggling for rhythm, direction, and identity under a coach yet to find his winning formula.
This is a story of two clubs heading in opposite directions: one ascending with momentum and belief, the other stagnating with more questions than answers.
Bunny Shaw City’s Relentless Goal Machine
When Manchester City signed Bunny Shaw in 2021, they knew they were acquiring a forward with raw pace, power, and instinct. What perhaps wasn’t immediately apparent was just how transformative she would become.
Against their latest opponents, Shaw showcased every quality that defines her game: composure under pressure, the ability to draw fouls in dangerous areas, and the precision to dispatch spot-kicks without hesitation. Her two penalties were taken with such authority that the goalkeeper had no chance, sending the City faithful into raptures.
These goals were not just about numbers — though Shaw’s stats are staggering. They were symbolic of a striker at the peak of her powers, carrying a team’s attacking hopes on her shoulders and delivering consistently. In a league that boasts world-class forwards, Shaw has carved her place as arguably the most feared striker.
The Importance of Shaw’s Consistency
For City, Shaw’s output is about more than goals. Her presence changes the dynamics of how opponents defend. Teams are forced to drop deeper, wary of her explosive pace in behind. Centre-backs are pinned back, unable to push forward into midfield, while full-backs hesitate to overlap for fear of leaving space. This tactical ripple effect creates room for City’s creative midfielders — players like Lauren Hemp and Chloe Kelly — to thrive. Shaw is not just finishing moves; she is the focal point around which City’s entire attacking system revolves.
Against her latest opposition, Shaw’s composure in high-pressure moments exemplified her mentality. Converting one penalty is challenging enough; to bury two in a single game, each with unerring confidence, reflects a striker who relishes responsibility.
City’s Title Credentials Strengthened
Shaw’s brace keeps Manchester City firmly in the title race. They look balanced, ruthless, and increasingly resilient — traits that were questioned in past campaigns when inconsistency often derailed their ambitions.
City’s midfield control, spearheaded by Keira Walsh’s intelligent distribution and Alex Greenwood’s leadership from defense, provides the platform for Shaw to thrive. Defensively, they look sharper, conceding fewer chances and dealing better with transitions.
This blend of solidity and firepower means City are now more than just contenders; they are genuine favorites. If Shaw maintains her form, City could very well lift silverware at the end of the season.
Liverpool’s Painful Afternoon Against Man Utd
While City soared, Liverpool endured another miserable outing. A 2-0 defeat to Manchester United highlighted the gulf between Taylor’s side and their rivals.
United approached the match with intensity and purpose, pressing high and exploiting Liverpool’s defensive vulnerabilities. Goals came at crucial moments, puncturing any confidence the Reds had tried to build. For Liverpool supporters, it was another reminder that progress under Gareth Taylor has been frustratingly elusive.
The performance lacked cohesion. The midfield struggled to link play, the defense looked disorganized under pressure, and the attack offered little threat. In truth, the scoreline could have been heavier had United been more clinical.
The Gareth Taylor Question
Taylor’s tenure as Liverpool manager has been marked by inconsistency and growing discontent among supporters. While he inherited a squad in transition, patience is wearing thin as the same patterns continue to repeat: blunt attacks, leaky defenses, and a lack of tactical clarity.
The defeat to United extends his winless streak, and the pressure is mounting. Fans are beginning to question whether Taylor has the vision or adaptability required to guide Liverpool back to the upper echelons of the WSL.
Post-match, Taylor struck a defiant tone, insisting that improvements will come with time. Yet, with every defeat, time feels like a luxury Liverpool can ill afford. In a league as competitive as the WSL, stagnation is dangerous.
A Tale of Contrasting Fortunes
The juxtaposition could not be sharper. Shaw’s brilliance has turned City into a ruthless machine, while Liverpool’s lack of inspiration under Taylor is dragging them further into mediocrity.
What makes this contrast even starker is that Liverpool once prided themselves on being one of the pioneers of women’s football in England. To now find themselves floundering while rivals surge ahead is a bitter pill for supporters who long for the glory days to return.
For City fans, meanwhile, optimism abounds. Shaw’s heroics symbolize not just individual excellence but a collective belief that this squad has what it takes to conquer the league.
Key Tactical Insights
-
Manchester City
-
-
- High Pressing: City pressed aggressively, forcing mistakes and earning set-piece opportunities, including penalties.
- Wide Play: Lauren Hemp’s width stretched the opposition, creating space for Shaw centrally.
- Ball Circulation: Keira Walsh and Yui Hasegawa orchestrated midfield transitions with precision.
-
-
Liverpool
- Fragile Defense: Too often caught out by simple through balls and crosses.
- Lack of Penetration: Forwards were isolated, struggling to link up with midfield.
- Passive Midfield: Unable to cope with United’s pressing, leading to turnovers.
Player Ratings
-
Manchester City
-
-
- Bunny Shaw (9/10): Two penalties converted, calm under pressure, relentless presence.
- Lauren Hemp (8/10): Electric down the wing, provided width and creativity.
- Keira Walsh (8/10): Controlled tempo, distributed superbly.
- Alex Greenwood (7.5/10): Commanding in defense, vocal leadership.
- Ellie Roebuck (7/10): Rarely tested but solid when called upon.
-
-
Liverpool
- Rachael Laws (GK) (6.5/10): Made some good saves, but exposed by defense.
- Gemma Bonner (5.5/10): Struggled with Shaw’s movement, often outpaced.
- Ceri Holland (6/10): Worked hard but lacked influence.
- Melissa Lawley (5.5/10): Offered little in attack, isolated on the wing.
- Sophie Roman Haug (6/10): Battled gamely, but service was poor.
Fan Reactions
On social media, reactions to both matches were immediate and passionate.
- City Fans: Praised Shaw’s composure and hailed her as the best striker in the league. Optimism is high that this could be their season.
- Liverpool Fans: Expressed frustration at the lack of progress under Taylor, with many calling for managerial changes. Some lamented the lack of ambition compared to rivals.
Implications for the Season
- Manchester City: With Shaw in peak form and the squad clicking, City look like genuine title challengers. Their ability to win tight games through moments of brilliance could prove decisive.
- Liverpool: The Reds risk being dragged into mid-table obscurity unless drastic improvements are made. With morale low and results poor, pressure on Taylor intensifies.
The Bigger Picture WSL’s Competitive Edge
These contrasting fortunes reflect the broader competitiveness of the WSL. The league has grown in stature, with fine margins often deciding outcomes. City’s rise and Liverpool’s struggles serve as a reminder that investment, vision, and tactical clarity are non-negotiable in the modern game.
While Bunny Shaw embodies the new era of superstars pushing the league to global relevance, Liverpool’s stagnation highlights the dangers of complacency in a rapidly evolving landscape.
Also Read:
