Jose Mourinho has revisited one of the most surprising decisions of his Manchester United tenure: choosing Scott McTominay ahead of Paul Pogba at a time when the Frenchman was the most expensive player in world football. The story resurfaced following Mourinho’s latest European success, offering a revealing insight into his managerial philosophy and belief in character over reputation.
After guiding Benfica to a composed 2–0 victory over Napoli in the sixth matchday of the Champions League league phase on Thursday night, Mourinho attended his post-match press conference carrying an unusual accessory—a small bag that immediately caught journalists’ attention. When asked what it contained, the veteran coach smiled and revealed it was Scott McTominay’s jersey.
“I played him,” Mourinho joked. “I benched Paul Pogba for him at Manchester United. The least he could do was give me his shirt.”
Behind the humor was a story that perfectly encapsulates Mourinho’s long-standing preference for discipline, reliability, and tactical intelligence over star power alone.
McTominay’s Manchester United Breakthrough Under Mourinho
Scott McTominay’s rise at Manchester United began quietly but decisively. His Premier League debut came in May 2017 against Arsenal at Old Trafford, when he was introduced late in the match as a substitute for Juan Mata. On that occasion, Pogba remained unused on the bench—an early signal that Mourinho saw something special in the young academy graduate.
Just two weeks later, with United rotating their squad ahead of the Europa League final, Mourinho handed McTominay his first senior start against Crystal Palace. The match featured a youthful midfield setup, with McTominay partnering Pogba alongside several other academy players, including Josh Harrop, Axel Tuanzebe, and Demetri Mitchell.
That night marked a turning point. McTominay’s calmness, physical presence, and willingness to follow instructions impressed Mourinho, who continued to trust him in high-pressure situations throughout subsequent seasons.
From Squad Player to Midfield Mainstay
What began as a developmental opportunity soon evolved into a defining role. McTominay grew into a consistent member of Manchester United’s senior squad, eventually making 255 appearances for the club across all competitions.
While Pogba’s United career was often disrupted by injuries, inconsistency, and external distractions, McTominay built a reputation as a dependable, tactically disciplined midfielder who rarely let his manager down. Mourinho’s faith was later validated under subsequent coaches, as McTominay remained a regular presence despite frequent managerial changes.
In 2024, the Scottish international made a bold move by leaving Old Trafford for Napoli. The decision proved transformative.
Flourishing in Italy: McTominay’s Napoli Evolution
Since arriving in Serie A, McTominay’s career has reached new heights. In less than a season and a half with Napoli, he has already scored 14 league goals—an extraordinary return for a midfielder previously known more for his defensive work than his attacking output.
His impact was instrumental in Napoli’s title-winning campaign last season, a contribution that earned him the Serie A Player of the Season award. The accolade confirmed his evolution into a complete, modern midfielder capable of influencing games at both ends of the pitch.
For Mourinho, McTominay’s success in Italy serves as long-term validation of a decision that once raised eyebrows in Manchester.
Mourinho’s Influence on McTominay’s International Career
Mourinho’s belief in McTominay extended beyond club football. The Portuguese coach also played a key role in shaping the midfielder’s international future.
Despite being born in England and eligible to represent the Three Lions, McTominay ultimately chose to play for Scotland. According to former Scotland manager Alex McLeish, Mourinho actively helped facilitate that decision.
McLeish recalled contacting Mourinho directly to arrange a meeting at Manchester United’s training ground, ahead of a planned visit from then-England manager Gareth Southgate.
“I called Jose that morning,” McLeish explained. “‘Come in at 12, we’ll have lunch and talk about Scott, then we’ll bring him in.’ Jose was incredibly cooperative.”
Following that meeting, McTominay expressed a clear desire to represent Scotland—a decision that has since defined his international career.
A Relationship Built on Trust and Respect
Years later, the bond between Mourinho and McTominay remains strong. Speaking on the High Performance podcast in 2024, the Napoli midfielder openly acknowledged the impact Mourinho had on his life.
“I owe him a lot,” McTominay said. “My family loves him. He gave me belief when it mattered most.”
That mutual respect explains why Mourinho still carries McTominay’s jersey with pride—and why he continues to highlight the midfielder as an example of what he values most in a player.
Character Over Reputation
The McTominay-Pogba decision was never about talent alone. It was about mentality, trust, and tactical commitment. While Pogba possessed extraordinary ability, Mourinho often questioned his consistency and focus. McTominay, by contrast, embodied the attributes Mourinho prizes above all else.
In hindsight, the decision looks less controversial and more prophetic. McTominay’s steady rise and current success underline a simple truth Mourinho has long preached: football rewards those who earn trust through discipline, humility, and relentless work.
For Mourinho, choosing McTominay over Pogba was not a gamble—it was a statement.
ALSO READ :
