Manchester United legend Nicky Butt has issued a dramatic warning amid the ongoing search for a new manager at Old Trafford. Butt has pledged to return his season tickets if the club goes ahead and appoints Enzo Maresca, the former Chelsea assistant, as Ruben Amorim’s successor.
The sudden vacancy at the United dugout, following Amorim’s dismissal, has fueled a whirlwind of speculation. Maresca, who recently parted ways with Chelsea, quickly emerged as a favorite candidate, drawing attention from pundits and former players alike.
Former Players Divided on Maresca Appointment
In discussions among ex-United stars, Paul Scholes even suggested Maresca as a potential option during a football debate. But Nicky Butt reacted strongly, categorically rejecting the idea. His objection, he clarified, isn’t about Maresca’s tactical ability but about his past affiliation with Manchester City, which Butt considers incompatible with United’s identity.
Strong Anti-City Sentiment
On the popular podcast The Good, The Bad and The Football, Scholes speculated that the timing of Maresca’s dismissal from Chelsea and Amorim’s sacking at United may not be coincidental. Butt, however, quickly interrupted, delivering a sharp retort.
Recruiting a figure so closely associated with Manchester City, Butt insisted, would be a grave error for the club’s culture and identity.
“If Maresca comes in – I like him as a coach, honestly – with his background, I will return my season tickets,” Butt declared firmly.
Scholes appeared surprised by the intensity of Butt’s response, but Butt made it clear that his principled stance stems from decades of fierce local rivalry.
Rejecting “Blue” Influence at Old Trafford
Butt expressed concern that Old Trafford is increasingly populated by figures with City connections, pointing out executives like Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox. Adding another former City man as manager, he argued, would be unacceptable to any true United supporter.
“Don’t misunderstand me. I can’t sit here and talk about Man United’s philosophy and DNA, then say, ‘I want Maresca, a former City man.’ And you already have Omar Berrada and Jason Wilcox,” Butt said, raising his voice.
“I don’t care how successful he is. You forget where I come from. Everyone else is a City fan. I’m a United fan, and I just can’t accept that.”
Maresca’s Manchester City Connection
Butt’s objections have a clear basis in Maresca’s history. The 44-year-old Italian coached Manchester City’s Elite Development Squad from 2020 to 2021, later returning in 2022 as assistant to Pep Guardiola before moving on to Leicester City.
Maresca was even reported to have been in discussions with City about succeeding Guardiola while still at Chelsea, further fueling Butt’s aversion. For the former United midfielder, any managerial link to City is a red line.
Gary Neville Urges Club to Avoid Experiments
Meanwhile, former United captain Gary Neville has focused on the technical and philosophical challenges of hiring a new manager. He warned the club to stop experimenting with tactical systems that confuse players and fans alike.
Neville cited Amorim’s failed three-center-back system as proof that misaligned managerial styles can harm the team. He stressed that United must return to attacking, entertaining football, staying true to the club’s identity.
“The experiments have to stop. There’s a great video online where Bobby Charlton talks about what it means to play for Man United,” Neville told Sky Sports.
“It’s about adventurous, exciting football, giving young players a chance, entertaining fans. Man United must take risks and play attacking football.”
Neville emphasized that the next manager must fully understand the club’s DNA, similar to how Barcelona and Ajax preserve their identities:
“Man United has to appoint a manager who aligns with the club’s DNA. Ajax will never change for anyone, Barcelona will never change for anyone,” Neville concluded.
The debate over Enzo Maresca’s potential appointment underscores the high stakes involved in selecting United’s next manager. For legends like Butt, club loyalty and historical rivalries carry as much weight as tactical acumen.
With Maresca’s City connections under the spotlight, and former players publicly voicing their concerns, Manchester United’s board faces intense pressure to make a decision that satisfies fans, preserves club identity, and restores stability at Old Trafford.
ALSO READ :
