Manchester United legends Paul Scholes and Nicky Butt have shared their views on the long-term future of Michael Carrick at Old Trafford. Despite Carrick’s impressive start as interim manager, both former teammates doubt he will secure a permanent managerial role at the club.
Carrick stepped into the managerial role to replace Ruben Amorim, taking on the responsibility of stabilizing the team until the end of the season. The plan is for Manchester United to appoint a permanent manager during the upcoming summer.
Carrick Impresses With Early Results
From the moment he took charge, Carrick grabbed attention. He led Manchester United to stunning victories over Manchester City and Arsenal, two of the top teams in the Premier League standings. These wins fueled speculation that Carrick could earn a full-time role.
However, the final decision rests with the club’s board. Despite the team’s positive performance under Carrick, some Manchester United legends remain cautious about his long-term suitability.
Scholes and Keane Agree: Making Carrick Permanent Is Risky
Even with the recent turnaround in results, not all former United stars are convinced Carrick should be given the full-time position. Roy Keane previously stated that Carrick should not take the permanent role, even if United qualifies for the Champions League, and Paul Scholes shares this opinion.
Speaking on the podcast The Good, The Bad, & The Football with Nicky Butt, Scholes explained:
“He stepped into this role when the situation had already been poor for a year, so it was almost impossible for it to get worse. The pressure is not as intense when you are an interim manager.”
Scholes added, “Once you take the job permanently at the start of next season, you suddenly have to win immediately. The board and fans will still carry the trauma from the Ole Gunnar Solskjaer era.”
He also pointed out that Carrick might struggle against top managerial candidates. “If Michael has to compete with someone like Thomas Tuchel next summer, there is only one winner when we talk about managing a top club and winning major trophies. It would be difficult for him to match that level.”
Nicky Butt: Carrick Has Bright Future Elsewhere
Nicky Butt agreed with Scholes’ assessment but emphasized that Carrick still has a promising managerial future at other clubs if he continues performing well at Manchester United.
“But Michael is intelligent and clever,” Butt said. “He understands the role he is in and what is required. I believe he could thrive at another club in the future.”
Carrick’s early success at Old Trafford demonstrates his tactical understanding and leadership qualities. He has stabilized the squad, improved team morale, and earned respect from players and fans alike. Yet, the challenge of taking over permanently at a club with high expectations is another matter entirely.
Interim Success vs. Permanent Pressure
Interim managers often enjoy a honeymoon period where expectations are relatively low. Carrick’s current achievements illustrate this principle. The team responds well under his guidance, and his calm demeanor has helped the squad navigate difficult fixtures.
However, transitioning from interim to permanent manager changes the stakes. Fans, board members, and media outlets expect immediate results. Every match becomes a test, and mistakes draw sharper criticism. Scholes highlighted that this sudden escalation of pressure could be a major hurdle for Carrick.
Comparing Carrick to Elite Managers
One of the main concerns from the legends is the competitive landscape of elite management. Modern top-tier managers possess extensive experience in winning domestic and European trophies. Scholes noted that competing with candidates like Thomas Tuchel or other proven managers could place Carrick at a disadvantage.
Even if Carrick proves capable tactically, the lack of prior permanent managerial experience at a club of Manchester United’s stature is a significant factor. Legends believe that the club may prefer a manager with a proven record in high-pressure environments to secure long-term success.
Opportunities Beyond Manchester United
While Manchester United may not offer Carrick a permanent position, former players believe his future in football coaching remains bright. Nicky Butt stressed that positive results and continued development at United could open doors elsewhere.
“Michael has shown intelligence, leadership, and tactical acumen. Other clubs would benefit from his skills and experience,” Butt explained. “Even if Manchester United decides to appoint someone else, he will have many opportunities to succeed elsewhere.”
Carrick’s reputation as a former player, his understanding of Manchester United’s culture, and his ability to inspire players give him a strong foundation for a managerial career. With careful career choices and continued growth, he could achieve significant success outside Old Trafford.
Looking Ahead
For now, Michael Carrick continues to steer Manchester United as interim manager. His victories over Manchester City and Arsenal highlight his potential. Still, according to legends like Scholes, Keane, and Butt, permanent leadership at United may not be the ideal path.
Carrick’s future will depend on the club’s summer decisions, the performance of potential managerial candidates, and his ability to maintain the team’s momentum. Whether he stays at Old Trafford or seeks opportunities elsewhere, Carrick’s early success has already reinforced his reputation as a tactically astute and respected football professional.
ALSO READ :
