Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher has publicly retracted his earlier comments claiming that Casemiro was “finished” and no longer fit to play for Manchester United. Carragher admitted that he had misjudged the Brazilian midfielder’s abilities and impact.
Casemiro joined Manchester United in 2022 and quickly became a key figure in the midfield. However, his performances dipped significantly last season, drawing criticism from pundits and fans alike. Among the critics was Carragher, who suggested that Casemiro had lost his sharpness and was no longer suitable for first-team action at Old Trafford.
Casemiro’s Remarkable Revival
The 2025/2026 season has proven otherwise. Casemiro has re-established himself as a vital presence in United’s squad, showcasing consistent performances week after week. Observing the midfielder’s resurgence, Carragher publicly acknowledged that his previous assessments were wrong and offered an apology.
During a recent Sky Sports broadcast, Carragher openly addressed Casemiro, praising his transformation and admitting his earlier criticism was unfounded.
“Look, he deserves credit because he now looks like a completely different player. He truly appears transformed, especially in his physicality,” Carragher explained.
From Criticism to Praise
Carragher revealed that his initial criticisms were largely based on Casemiro’s physical condition at the time, which seemed unfit for top-level football.
“When I criticized him before, you could see he looked like an older player approaching the end of his career,” Carragher said.
However, this season, Casemiro has completely transformed his physique, displaying exceptional fitness and professionalism. Carragher emphasized the stark contrast between the midfielder’s previous and current form.
“Now everything looks different. He appears ultra-professional, and his body looks completely renewed. The difference is night and day,” he added.
Casemiro’s Impact at Manchester United
Casemiro’s revival has been critical for Manchester United as the team pursues top-four and Champions League qualification ambitions. His leadership in midfield, defensive solidity, and ability to control the tempo of games have made him indispensable to United’s setup this season.
Statistics from this campaign show Casemiro consistently contributing to both defensive and offensive phases, offering interceptions, tackles, and precise passing that have helped United stabilize results.
Carragher’s reversal of opinion highlights how even seasoned analysts can misjudge a player’s resilience and adaptability. Casemiro’s work ethic, professionalism, and on-field performances have proven that he still possesses the qualities of a world-class midfielder.
Final Season at Old Trafford
Despite his resurgence, Casemiro will only be at Manchester United until the end of the 2025/2026 season. The Brazilian confirmed that he will leave Old Trafford once his contract expires in the summer.
Fans and pundits alike will look back on Casemiro’s time at United as a story of redemption and determination, especially given his ability to bounce back from criticism and regain peak form in his mid-30s.
His departure will leave a gap in United’s midfield, and finding a replacement with similar influence and experience will be a key challenge for the club in the upcoming transfer window.
Carragher’s Reflection
Carragher’s apology is a rare instance of a high-profile pundit publicly acknowledging an incorrect judgment. He stressed that Casemiro’s current performances are a testament to professionalism and dedication, qualities that should serve as a lesson for critics and analysts alike.
“It’s important to recognize players when they evolve and prove us wrong. Casemiro has done that this season. He’s shown incredible commitment to his craft and has become a game-changer for Manchester United,” Carragher said.
Legacy at Manchester United
As Casemiro prepares for his final months at United, his legacy is already taking shape. Beyond statistics, his leadership, consistency, and resilience define his tenure at Old Trafford. Young players and teammates have likely benefited from his presence both on and off the pitch, making him a model professional.
Even critics like Carragher now acknowledge the transformative effect Casemiro has had on Manchester United this season. His final games will be closely watched by fans and analysts, eager to see the midfielder’s final impact before he departs for the next chapter of his career.
ALSO READ :
