Aston Villa entered the 2025 season with high hopes under Unai Emery, a coach who has revitalized the club with tactical intelligence and a winning mentality. Known for his structured defensive setups combined with sharp attacking transitions, Villa’s brand of football has earned admiration across the Premier League. Yet, recent weeks have seen a concerning pattern: a goal drought.
With the FA Cup clash against Sunderland looming, fans and pundits alike are asking: What is behind Villa’s sudden struggle to find the net?
This article explores the unseen and often overlooked factors contributing to this dry spell, from tactical tweaks and squad fatigue to psychological barriers and opposition adjustments.
The Numbers Behind the Drought
A quick look at the statistics paints a worrying picture:
- Villa have scored just two goals in their last five matches, compared to 11 in the five before that.
- Their expected goals (xG) remain relatively high at 1.6 per game, suggesting chances are being created but not finished.
- Their shot conversion rate has dropped from 14% to under 8% during this spell.
These figures suggest the issue is not necessarily about creativity but about execution, confidence, and consistency.
Factor 1 Tactical Adjustments and Opponent Awareness
Unai Emery’s system relies heavily on structured buildup and precise timing of forward runs. Opponents, however, appear to have done their homework:
- Pressing Traps: Teams now press Villa’s double pivot more aggressively, cutting supply lines to the forwards.
- Crowded Central Zones: Midfield playmakers like Douglas Luiz and Youri Tielemans are often surrounded, reducing through-ball opportunities.
- Deeper Defensive Blocks: Opponents are willing to concede possession, forcing Villa to break them down—a situation they find harder to manage.
While Emery thrives on tactical adaptability, his reliance on repeated patterns of play makes Villa predictable at times.
Factor 2 Fatigue and Rotation Challenges
Villa’s resurgence under Emery has come with increased commitments: domestic competitions, European football, and intense Premier League schedules.
- Heavy Workload: Key attackers like Ollie Watkins and Leon Bailey have logged significant minutes. Fatigue affects sharpness, particularly finishing.
- Injury List: Sporadic absences of creative sparks such as Moussa Diaby have disrupted rhythm.
- Rotation Risks: Emery has rotated to protect players, but replacements often lack the same chemistry.
This accumulation of physical and mental strain plays a subtle yet critical role in attacking inefficiency.
Factor 3 Psychological Pressure and Confidence Issues
Football is as much mental as it is physical. When goals dry up, confidence takes a hit.
- Missed Chances Become a Burden: Watkins, usually clinical, has missed three big chances in recent games. Each miss adds pressure.
- Team Tension: Players overthink in the final third, opting for safer passes rather than instinctive finishes.
- Supporter Expectation: With Villa now expected to compete for European spots consistently, the weight of expectation intensifies during dry spells.
Emery, known for meticulous preparation, is also tasked with rebuilding morale and freedom in attacking play.
Factor 4 Dependence on Key Individuals
Villa’s attack often leans heavily on a few names:
- Ollie Watkins: Primary striker and focal point. If he struggles, goals tend to dry up.
- Leon Bailey: Provides width and directness, but his form fluctuates.
- Moussa Diaby: Adds unpredictability, though injuries have limited his impact.
The over-reliance means that when one or two of these players are off-form or unavailable, Villa lack alternative goal threats. Squad depth, while improved, is still not at the level of top-four rivals.
Factor 5 Set-Piece Decline
Earlier in the season, Villa were among the most dangerous sides from corners and free kicks. Recently, however:
- Deliveries have been less consistent.
- Opponents defend with more discipline, often doubling on aerial threats like Tyrone Mings or Pau Torres.
- Second-ball opportunities are not being capitalized on.
Losing this edge removes an important scoring avenue, especially in tight matches.
Factor 6 Opponent-Specific Challenges
A closer inspection of recent fixtures reveals Villa’s struggles are not entirely self-inflicted.
- Against Top Sides: Facing tactically astute managers, Villa often found themselves outmaneuvered.
- Against Low Blocks: Teams like Brentford and Crystal Palace frustrated them by defending deep.
- Away Fatigue: On the road, their pressing intensity dips, reducing turnover chances high up the pitch.
Thus, context matters. The drought, while worrying, also reflects the level of opposition faced.
Factor 7 Transition Inefficiency
Villa’s attack thrives on quick transitions—winning the ball in midfield and striking before defenses reset. Recently, however:
- Turnovers are less frequent due to cautious pressing.
- Opponents deliberately slow the game to nullify Villa’s speed.
- Midfielders are more conservative, reducing risk-taking passes.
This blunts Villa’s natural strength and forces them into slower, less effective buildup play.
Factor 8 Statistical Anomalies and Luck
Sometimes, droughts are simply about luck.
- In two matches, Villa hit the post three times.
- Opposition goalkeepers produced exceptional saves—such as Wolves’ keeper making eight saves in one match.
- Deflections and ricochets have favored opponents rather than Villa attackers.
Over the long run, such anomalies tend to balance out. The challenge is surviving the period without losing confidence.
The Sunderland Clash A Timely Opportunity
The upcoming match against Sunderland in the FA Cup could be the perfect platform to reset.
- Sunderland, while spirited in the Championship, lack Premier League-level defensive organization.
- The fixture offers Emery a chance to rotate while still fielding a strong enough side to dominate.
- A few goals here could reignite confidence, particularly for Watkins and Bailey.
The key will be treating the match with professionalism while using it as a confidence-builder.
Unai Emery’s Approach to Solving the Drought
Emery is renowned for his tactical flexibility. To address the goal drought, he may explore:
- Tweaked Formations
- Shifting from 4-2-3-1 to 4-4-2 could bring Watkins closer to a partner, reducing isolation.
- Using Bailey or Diaby centrally at times for unpredictability.
- Greater Squad Rotation
- Introducing fresh legs like Jhon Durán to add energy and directness.
- Giving academy players chances in cup games.
- Psychological Boosts
- Emphasizing past successes in team talks.
- Reducing pressure by framing the drought as temporary.
- Training Focus
- Repetition of finishing drills under pressure.
- Recreating match scenarios where patience is key.
Voices from the Dressing Room
Players have been candid about the challenge:
- Ollie Watkins: “Strikers live on goals. When they don’t come, you feel it. But I know it only takes one game to change everything.”
- Douglas Luiz: “We are still creating chances. It’s not about ability—it’s about confidence and timing. We trust the goals will return.”
- Unai Emery: “Our system works. But football is about details. We will keep improving, and I believe the goals will come back.”
Media and Fan Perspectives
Pundits have debated whether Villa’s drought is a blip or a warning sign.
- Some argue Emery’s side is overachieving given their squad depth, and occasional dips are inevitable.
- Others suggest Villa need January reinforcements, particularly a versatile forward.
Fans remain largely supportive but anxious. On social media, sentiments range from encouragement—“We back the boys to bounce back”—to worry: “We can’t afford to waste chances if we want top-four.”
Comparing Villa’s Situation with Rivals
Villa’s struggles mirror phases experienced by other clubs:
- Arsenal (2022–23): Went through a mini drought before recovering to challenge for the title.
- Tottenham (2024–25): Relied too heavily on Son and Kane; when form dipped, goals dried up.
- Newcastle United: Faced similar fatigue balancing domestic and European commitments.
The common theme? Depth and adaptability matter. Villa are now learning the same lesson.
Long-Term Outlook Should Fans Be Concerned
While the drought is frustrating, several reasons suggest optimism:
- Chances Are Still Being Created: Poor finishing can be corrected more easily than a lack of creativity.
- Emery’s Tactical Acumen: Few coaches adjust better mid-season.
- Fixture Relief: Upcoming matches against lower-ranked sides could provide a platform to regain rhythm.
If Villa capitalize, the drought may soon be remembered as a brief hiccup rather than a major crisis.
Also Read:
