Liverpool is confronting a significant dilemma this January transfer window. Reports suggest that vice-captain Andy Robertson has drawn the attention of Tottenham Hotspur, raising concerns about the potential impact of losing the experienced left-back mid-season.
While Robertson’s departure could generate immediate transfer income, it is widely regarded as a high-risk decision for the Reds, who are navigating a crucial period in both domestic and European competitions.
The Importance of Robertson at Liverpool
Andy Robertson has been an integral figure in Liverpool’s resurgence over the past decade. The 31-year-old has contributed to two Premier League titles, one UEFA Champions League trophy, and multiple domestic cups, becoming a cornerstone of both the squad and the dressing room.
Beyond his defensive responsibilities, Robertson serves as a leader on and off the pitch, organizing Liverpool’s backline and providing guidance to younger players. His presence is considered vital for team cohesion, particularly during high-pressure matches in the Premier League and Champions League.
However, Robertson’s contract situation has complicated matters. Set to become a free agent in the summer, his position in the first team has become less certain, especially following the arrival of Milos Kerkez, which further limits his opportunities as a regular starter at left-back.
Tottenham, managed by Thomas Frank, has reportedly expressed strong interest in securing Robertson’s signature immediately, rather than waiting until his contract expires. The prospect of a January move poses a potential threat to Liverpool’s defensive stability.
Defensive Depth Under Threat
Should Robertson depart, Liverpool’s defensive depth would face a serious challenge. Currently, manager Arne Slot would have only five defenders available to cover four positions in the backline.
Kerkez and Jeremie Frimpong are the sole natural full-backs available, while Joe Gomez, Ibrahima Konate, and Virgil van Dijk occupy central defensive roles. Both Gomez and Konate have struggled with recurring injuries, casting doubt on Liverpool’s ability to maintain a fully fit defense throughout the remainder of the 2025/2026 season.
Liverpool is reportedly planning to recall Kostas Tsimikas from his loan at AS Roma. Yet, the Greek left-back lacks versatility, only able to play at left-back and not as a central defender. Robertson’s experience in multiple defensive roles makes him a critical emergency option in case of injury or suspension.
Even with Premier League title hopes fading, Liverpool still requires a strong defensive foundation to remain competitive in the Champions League and FA Cup. Relying on a thin defensive roster could jeopardize results in crucial fixtures.
Tsimikas Alone Isn’t Enough
Tsimikas holds a special place among Liverpool fans, particularly for his decisive penalty in the 2022 FA Cup final against Chelsea. However, his contributions in recent seasons have been inconsistent.
During his loan spell at Roma, Tsimikas has seen minimal game time, accumulating only 379 minutes this season. His limited impact and inability to displace Robertson as a starter last season highlight that he may not be ready to shoulder full defensive responsibilities for Liverpool.
In high-stakes matches, Robertson’s experience—both on the field and in the locker room—remains invaluable. His departure could leave Liverpool vulnerable, particularly if Kerkez faces injury challenges.
Contract Dilemma
Selling Robertson in January would also create strategic headaches for Liverpool ahead of the summer transfer window. The club would likely need to recruit at least two defenders to maintain squad balance.
With Konate potentially leaving on a free transfer, Liverpool could be left with only three central defenders. Additionally, Kerkez requires a reliable backup at left-back. With Virgil van Dijk turning 35 in the 2026/2027 season, relying on him for every match carries inherent risk. Summer reinforcements would become essential to ensure stability in the defensive unit.
Moreover, Liverpool’s midfield and attack could require reinforcement if Mohamed Salah departs, further complicating transfer priorities.
A Strategic Solution
Despite Robertson’s recent dip in form, extending his contract and retaining him as a backup could be a pragmatic approach. Maintaining Robertson until the summer would alleviate one major transfer need, preserve squad stability, and provide critical defensive cover during this transitional period.
Keeping Robertson would allow Liverpool to navigate the remainder of the season with greater confidence, ensuring experienced leadership in the squad while strategically planning for summer signings. The decision could be pivotal in balancing short-term results with long-term squad development.
In conclusion, while Robertson’s January exit to Tottenham may appear tempting, the risks far outweigh the immediate benefits. Liverpool must carefully weigh the defensive and leadership void his departure would create, considering both domestic and European ambitions. Maintaining him for the remainder of the season may ultimately prove to be the smarter, more strategic choice.
ALSO READ :
