Manchester United have been tipped to suffer another setback in their Boxing Day clash against Newcastle United, with former England striker and respected pundit Chris Sutton predicting defeat for the Red Devils at Old Trafford.
The Premier League fixture, scheduled for the early hours of Boxing Day 2025, sees Manchester United host Newcastle United in what promises to be a tense and closely contested encounter. Both sides have struggled for consistency in recent weeks, increasing the pressure to deliver a positive result during the festive period.
Despite United playing at home, Sutton believes the balance of the contest favors Newcastle—particularly due to the absence of a key figure in the United lineup.
Sutton Predicts United Setback at Old Trafford
Offering his analysis on BBC Sport, Sutton acknowledged that Manchester United showed encouraging signs in their recent defeat to Aston Villa. However, he insisted that improved performances alone would not be enough to secure points against a well-organized Newcastle side.
“Manchester United received some praise for their performance against Aston Villa, even though they lost that game,” Sutton explained. “But this is another big test, and I don’t see them getting the result they want here.”
While many observers expect a tight contest, Sutton’s prediction stands out for its clarity. In his view, Newcastle’s overall structure and balance give them a crucial edge heading into the match.
Life Without Bruno Fernandes a Major Concern
Central to Sutton’s assessment is the absence of Bruno Fernandes, who is sidelined through injury. The Portuguese international has long been United’s creative leader, and his unavailability significantly alters the team’s dynamics.
“The key issue for United is how they cope without Bruno Fernandes,” Sutton said. “When you look at Ruben Amorim’s team, there are not many natural leaders on the pitch without him.”
According to Sutton, Fernandes’ influence goes beyond goals and assists. His presence often dictates tempo, provides direction in possession, and lifts teammates during difficult moments. Without him, United risk looking disjointed, especially in midfield.
Tactical Questions for Ruben Amorim
Sutton also raised questions about how United head coach Ruben Amorimmight attempt to compensate for Fernandes’ absence. One intriguing option, previously used against Aston Villa, involves deploying Lisandro Martínez in a deeper midfield role.
“It will be interesting to see whether Amorim uses Lisandro Martínez as a holding midfielder again, like he did against Villa,” Sutton noted. “I think he could provide some of the leadership United desperately need in this game.”
Such a move would represent a tactical gamble. While Martínez offers aggression and composure, shifting him out of defense could expose United at the back—particularly against Newcastle’s physical attacking approach.
Why Newcastle Hold the Advantage
Despite Newcastle’s underwhelming away form—having won just one of their last eight Premier League matches on the road—Sutton still believes they are better equipped for this particular contest.
“Newcastle’s away record isn’t great,” Sutton admitted. “But right now, they simply have a stronger squad than Manchester United.”
Under the guidance of Eddie Howe, the Magpies have built a side known for discipline, intensity, and tactical clarity. Even when results have dipped, their performances have remained relatively stable compared to United’s uneven displays.
Sutton expects the game to be low-scoring, shaped by caution rather than attacking flair. “I don’t think there will be many goals,” he added. “I’m going for a narrow 1–0 win for Newcastle.”
A Worrying Head-to-Head Record for United
Beyond current form and injuries, Manchester United face another psychological hurdle: their recent record against Newcastle. The Red Devils have lost five of their last six meetings with the Magpies, a statistic that adds further weight to Sutton’s prediction.
Those defeats have often followed a similar pattern, with United struggling to control midfield battles and cope with Newcastle’s pressing game. Unless Amorim can address those issues, history suggests another difficult night could be in store.
Boxing Day Pressure Builds
Boxing Day fixtures carry unique significance in English football, particularly at Old Trafford, where expectations are always high. For Manchester United, the occasion offers a chance to restore belief among supporters—but it also magnifies any shortcomings.
Without Fernandes, and with leadership questions unresolved, United face a demanding challenge. Newcastle, meanwhile, arrive with less pressure and a clear tactical identity, factors that Sutton believes could prove decisive.
A Test of Character for United
While predictions remain just that, Sutton’s analysis highlights genuine concerns for Manchester United heading into the festive clash. Injuries, leadership gaps, and a poor recent record against Newcastle combine to paint a difficult picture.
For Amorim and his players, Boxing Day represents more than just another league fixture—it is a test of adaptability and resilience. Whether United can defy Sutton’s forecast and reverse their recent fortunes against Newcastle will soon be revealed under the Old Trafford lights.
ALSO READ :
