English football pundit Jamie Carragher has publicly admitted that he underestimated Manchester United star Casemiro. In May 2024, Carragher reportedly told the Brazilian midfielder that his top-level career was effectively over. However, Casemiro has since silenced the critics, delivering an impressive string of performances in the Premier League and emerging as a key figure for the Red Devils.
Most recently, the 33-year-old opened the scoring and provided a brilliant assist for Matheus Cunha’s second goal in Manchester United’s 3-2 victory over Fulham on Sunday (February 1, 2026). These contributions reflect Casemiro’s continued importance in United’s midfield, whether under former manager Ruben Amorim or now interim coach Michael Carrick.
Casemiro Establishes Himself as a Premier League Force
This season, Casemiro has become a regular fixture in Manchester United’s starting XI. Carrick has consistently deployed a midfield trio of Casemiro, Kobbie Mainoo, and Bruno Fernandes, which has proven highly effective, producing three consecutive league victories against top teams such as Manchester City, Arsenal, and Fulham.
Casemiro’s contract is set to expire at the end of the 2026 season, and the midfielder has confirmed he will depart Old Trafford during the summer, even bidding farewell in an emotional video message. Despite his upcoming exit, he leaves with a legacy far removed from the doubts voiced in 2024.
Carragher Reflects on Past Criticism
Carragher first publicly doubted Casemiro after witnessing Manchester United’s heavy 0-4 defeat to Crystal Palace. At the time, he remarked, “I always remember the saying ‘leave football before football leaves you.’ Football had left him. At this level, he needed to end his career and move on.”
Now, the former Liverpool defender has admitted he was wrong. Casemiro has not only revived his career but has done so impressively, aided by improved physical conditioning and professional dedication.
“I think what Casemiro has achieved at Manchester United is a perfect example of what is expected from a high-level signing,” Carragher told Sky Sports. “His first season was fantastic, so everyone knew he was a great player, and indeed, he is. Now, in his final season, he’s performing at a high level, and he will be remembered fondly. His middle years at United were challenging, but there’s no doubt he’s bounced back.”
Carragher also highlighted that Casemiro’s form has been consistently strong, not just in the recent Fulham match, but also in high-pressure fixtures away at Arsenal and during home clashes with Manchester City. “It’s fair to say football hasn’t left him, considering what he’s achieved this season in the Premier League,” he added.
Casemiro Shows Remarkable Transformation
The 48-year-old pundit even acknowledged that Casemiro could respond to his past remarks with humor or sharp retorts. “Casemiro has every right to say, ‘leave punditry before punditry leaves you,’ if he wants to. He could easily throw that back at me,” Carragher admitted.
He praised the midfielder’s transformation, noting, “Honestly, give him credit. He looks like a completely different player now. Physically, he’s changed. When I made those comments, he looked like an older man nearing the end of his career. Whether he had relaxed slightly before or has now become extremely professional, physically he is worlds apart.”
Carrick Confident in Casemiro’s Commitment
Michael Carrick, who now oversees Manchester United, confirmed that Casemiro’s announced departure had been planned before his arrival as interim coach. “I think the announcement regarding Casemiro was made for clarity. The decision was taken before I came in, so this wasn’t a reactive choice,” Carrick explained.
Carrick emphasized the midfielder’s professionalism and mental focus. “With his personality and character, you can see it in his performances. He’s fully committed to finishing the season strongly and doing his utmost for the team. I’ve spoken to him, and he is determined to perform and end the season on a high. I have no doubts about him at all,” Carrick added.
Casemiro’s Legacy at Manchester United
As Casemiro prepares to leave Manchester United in the summer, his influence on the team is undeniable. He has not only provided goals and assists but has also offered leadership, consistency, and experience in midfield. His resurgence under Carrick and earlier under Amorim illustrates his resilience and adaptability, turning initial doubts into admiration.
Fans and pundits alike now recognize Casemiro as a player who has left a lasting mark at Old Trafford. From being doubted by commentators like Carragher to becoming one of United’s most reliable performers, his journey highlights the value of perseverance, professionalism, and maintaining peak physical condition.
Casemiro’s farewell season promises to be remembered not for past controversies or criticisms, but for his significant contributions in one of the most competitive leagues in the world. He has redefined expectations for players in their early thirties and leaves Manchester United with an enduring legacy of dedication and excellence.
ALSO READ :
